← The Bonus Podcast

Transforming Employee Roles from Transactional to Partnership Through Strategic Bonus Plans

Nov 19, 2026 · 8 min

Show notes

Is simply paying a salary enough to motivate employees, or should you reward them with bonuses for meeting expectations? This episode of The Bonus Podcast dives into this hotly debated question, challenging traditional compensation models and exploring the real key to building a team of business partners not just workers.

The conversation focused on the difference between transactional and partnership-based relationships in the workplace. It raised the core question: should employees receive bonuses for fulfilling their job descriptions, or is their paycheck enough of a reward? The discussion explored how business owners can create incentive structures that drive more than mere compliance, fostering true engagement and ownership among their teams.

A key theme that emerged was the importance of aligning employee goals with the business’s strategic direction. Rather than offering generic bonuses, the conversation unpacked a three-part method for designing effective bonus pools ensuring incentives are tied to company profitability, strategic progress, and individual performance.

Key Takeaways

  • The discussion explored why viewing bonuses as a profit-generating investment, rather than a cost, can transform company culture and growth potential 06:32.
  • One concept discussed was the need to bridge job roles with organizational objectives, ensuring employees contribute directly to business growth 01:28.
  • Several points were raised, including a three-part bonus plan:

  1. A portion of the bonus pool is distributed if the company hits its profitability targets not just revenue 02:41.
  2. Employees share in the bonus when quarterly or annual strategic goals (“rocks”) are achieved 03:54.
  3. Each employee’s individual “critical result” , a metric they fully control, should be rewarded if achieved alongside company goals 04:47.

  • The conversation emphasized that well-designed incentives channel employee energy toward collective business advancement, transforming the relationship from transactional to truly collaborative 05:54.
  • If you want employees to care and act like business partners, clarity around goals, progress checkpoints, and personal contributions is essential 06:47.

Don’t let your bonus plan be an afterthought or just a line item in your budget. Tune in to this episode to discover actionable strategies that help your team think and act like true partners in your company’s success. For more tools and insights to engage your employees and drive your business forward, subscribe to The Bonus Podcast and join the conversation!

Listen now and start building a culture where everyone has a reason to care!

Read the full transcript

Bonus_Podcast_Episode_5.txt

100%

Andrew Lamppa [00:00:03]:

Should you really pay your employees extra for doing a job that you already hired them to do and you're already paying them to do? Well, that's what we're exploring on the Bonus Podcast, because honestly, I think the answer is yes. Hi, I'm Andrew Lampa, and this is the Bonus Podcast. You hire a team, you hire an employee, you have a great job description, you know exactly what they're supposed to do, you pay them a good salary or wage or hourly rate, Should you also pay them a bonus or incentive for doing the job? Or is, is doing the job the reward? Or is the salary the reward for doing the job? Well, I think the question really is, what kind of relationship do you want with your employees? Do you want it to be purely transactional? Or do you want it to be relational and a partnership? Because if you want it just to be transactional, show up, clock in, clock out, do the work, get paid, and just rinse and repeat, then no, you probably shouldn't pay them a bonus because that's not what you want. But if you want a partner in the business, if you want employees who are going to take ownership, and they're going to actively help you build the business you want, then I say yes. But there's a little work that has to be done because if it's simply just paying them for doing what's on their job description, then you're not going to get the results you want. You see, to turn the transactional relationship into a partnership, you want to make sure that the, the job description and the goals and the objective of the employee are going to help get the business where you want it to go. Because if they won't, then there's not going to be a connection and your employees won't be adding extra value to the company. The question isn't, should I pay them more for doing their job? The question should be, how do I create a job? How do I organize and communicate their job to where if they do their job well, they will help actually build the company we want to build? Now, one way to do that is by having a 3-part method for pool, uh, bonus pool distributions.

Andrew Lamppa [00:02:16]:

See, I believe a bonus, an incentive plan, there's 2 parts. There's a way to put money in the pool, and then there's ways to take money out of the pool. So we're gonna go over the 3 ways of how you do bonus distributions to make sure your employees aren't just transactional, but they're actually partners in helping you build the business. So the first step, the first slice, is did the company hit their profitability goals? Now you don't want to do revenue, you want to do profits. If the company set a target, if they hit that target, if it's a proper target, then you want to pay out a portion of the bonus pool to your employees because the work they did got your business to a place where you wanted it to go in the first place. So it may not be a big percentage, but a percentage of the bonus pool automatically should get distributed if we simply hit our financial and profitability goals. The second part is our quarterly goals, objectives, rocks, whatever you want to call it. If you're doing the work that you need to do and run your business, every business should have some annual objective, some quarterly objective, maybe monthly objective, though we'll focus on quarterly for a second, where we're building and improving the business.

Andrew Lamppa [00:03:30]:

You see, if the business just day in and day out does the exact same thing, but there's no strategy behind where we're going, what we want to build and create, then the business is going to struggle. But if we have a plan on improving the business, iterating on the business, setting targets and goals, then you can bring your employees in and they can partner with you. So a good strategic plan has quarterly goals or rocks or objectives. If the employees can help you hit those rocks, hit that big goal, or if it's an annual goal, break it up into 4 checkpoints where our goal by the end of the year is to have this level of profit, or ideally like a performance issue, like realization or utilization or systems in place. But Q1, we need to have this in place. Q2, we need to be at this rate. Q3 and Q4, now you're bringing them in. You're going to partner with your employees to build this amazing company.

Andrew Lamppa [00:04:22]:

If after Q1 you hit those quarterly goals or objectives, then absolutely pay out the bonus, distribute a portion of the bonus pool to your employees. That is how you bring them in and partner with them and remove this transactional relationship. Lastly is the individual employee performance. And this is critical. Every employee should have what I call a critical result. This is that one number that if all else fails, they need to hit this number. It has to be a number that they have control over. It can't be top-line sales unless they're a salesperson.

Andrew Lamppa [00:04:58]:

It can't be production numbers if they're not connected to production. So their idea or their, what I call as a critical result, needs to be something that they have full control over. And this would be documented on their job description or tool I use called an employee success agreement or ESA, where they know exactly their responsibilities. They know what success looks like for every one of those responsibilities, and they have a singular critical result That if they hit it and the company hit their profit threshold, then a portion of the bonus pool gets distributed because of that. So there's 3 ways a properly designed incentive plan gets paid out. First way is if we hit our financial or profitability goals. The second way is if we hit our quarterly goals or rocks. And lastly, if the— if every individual employee hit their critical result.

Andrew Lamppa [00:05:54]:

You put those 3 things in place, you will now have an employee that no longer thinks of this working relationship as transactional— walk in, clock in, do the work, clock out, leave— but they're going to come in, they're going to clock in, they're going to do the work, but they're also going to be thinking, how can we hit these goals? How can we hit these objectives that we've set forth at the beginning of the quarter, halfway through, end of the quarter? And you're gonna build it. You're gonna build a partnership. If you're thinking, man, I already pay them so much, I can't afford to pay them more, then start thinking about it not from thinking of a bonus as a cost center, but as a profit generator. You're not taking money out of current profits to pay out as a bonus. You're looking at additional growth, additional success, additional profits. And by doing so, your employees can partner with you and building the business that you want to build. A lot of business owners don't have these clear annual goals. If you want to be a business owner that does, come up with a plan, seek out the help you need to create annual goals, to create those quarterly checkpoints or mile markers, and bring your team along for the ride.

Andrew Lamppa [00:07:03]:

So should I bonus someone for doing their job? On the surface, if their job is very transactional, no. But are their targets connected to where we want the business to go? If you do that and organize and strategize and and create a properly designed incentive plan? Absolutely, bonus the heck out of them. I'm Andrew Lampa, and this is the Bonus Podcast, helping you give your employees a reason to care.

Displaying Bonus_Podcast_Episode_5.txt.

Andrew Lamppa

Meet Andrew Lamppa

Andrew Lamppa is a business coach, former 25-employee business owner and founder of Built to Benefit.

Before coaching business owners, Andrew spent 14 years building and operating his own company, which was running at 4x his industry’s profitability and 8x his industry’s growth at the time it was acquired in 2018. Along the way, he became fascinated with a question many small-business owners struggle with:

How do you get employees to care about the success of the business without expecting them to act like owners while giving them none of the upside?

Today, Andrew works with small-business owners to improve employee ownership, performance, profitability and leadership systems.

The Bonus Podcast is where he explores one of his favorite pieces of that puzzle: how businesses pay, measure, reward and incentivize the people helping build them.

Get Started →